What is a contingent practical identity?

What is a contingent practical identity?

the value of humanity must be given up” (130).9 In other words, a contingent. practical identity is normative for a person in the sense of being morally. permissible so long as it does not fundamentally conflict with the moral law. Let us refer to morally permissible practical identities as weakly normative.

What does Korsgaard say is the source of obligation?

In Korsgaard’s view those obligations can be accounted for as deriving from the reflective rejection of everything that one perceives as a threat to one’s identity (Korsgaard 1996a, 100, 113–25).

What is practical identity?

This ‘practical identity’ pertains to the agent’s sense of self, and is defined as ‘a description under which you value yourself, a description under which you find your life to be worth living and your actions to be worth undertaking’ (Korsgaard, 1996a, p.

What is a necessary practical identity?

This ‘practical identity’ pertains to the agent’s sense of self, and is defined as ‘a description under which you value yourself, a description under which you find your life to be worth living and your actions to be worth undertaking’ (Korsgaard, 1996a, p. 101).

What is the normative question according to Korsgaard?

The normative question refers to what one asks oneself when considering whether one is obligated by a particular moral claim, and it essentially serves to illustrate the necessity of justifying these claims from a first-person perspective.

What is an example of a normative question?

For example, speaking again about minimum wage laws, a positive question would be “Do higher minimum wages cause higher rates of youth unemployment?”, whereas a normative question might be “Are higher minimum wages better for young workers?” The first of those two questions should have a testable answer: yes or no.

What’s a normative question?

Normative questions are about what is allowed or what is good. These questions should not be confused with conceptual questions or descriptive questions (see below). In most cases normative questions implies philosophical (not empirical) research. Empirical questions are about ‘truth’ and ‘observations’.

What is an example of a positive statement?

Positive statements are thus the opposite of normative statements. Positive statements are based on empirical evidence. For examples, “An increase in taxation will result in less consumption” and “A fall in supply of petrol will lead to an increase in its price”.

What are examples of positive economics?

Here’s an example of a positive economic statement: “Government-provided healthcare increases public expenditures.” This statement is fact-based and has no value judgment attached to it. Its validity can be proven (or disproven) by studying healthcare spending where governments provide healthcare.

What is an example of normative question?

What is an example of a normative statement?

An example of a normative economic statement is as follows: The price of milk should be $6 a gallon to give dairy farmers a higher living standard and to save the family farm. This is a normative statement, because it reflects value judgments. Capitalist normative economic philosophy is attributed to Adam Smith.

Do positive statements need to be true?

A positive statement must be both testable and true.